Skip to content

Back-in-stock notifications not sent for attribute combinations with multiple warehouses #881

Open

Description

@KrzysztofPajak

Description

When a product uses stock management by attribute combinations with multiple warehouses, raising the stock of a combination's warehouse in the admin panel does not send back-in-stock notifications to subscribers.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Create a product, published, with Manage inventory method = Manage stock by attributes, Use multiple warehouses enabled, Allow out of stock subscriptions enabled and Backorders = No backorders.
  2. Add an attribute combination with warehouse stock 0 in one warehouse.
  3. As a customer, subscribe to the "notify me when available" for that combination.
  4. In admin, edit the combination (edit popup) and raise that warehouse's stock above 0.
  5. No notification is queued for the subscriber.

Cause

ProductViewModelService.InsertOrUpdateProductAttributeCombinationPopup (src/Web/Grand.Web.AdminShared/Services/ProductViewModelService.cs, ~line 2239) snapshots the previous state with combination.Clone(). ProductAttributeCombination.Clone() (src/Core/Grand.Domain/Catalog/ProductAttributeCombination.cs, line 87) is MemberwiseClone(), a shallow copy, so the WarehouseInventory list and its items are shared between the clone and the original.

PrepareCombinationWarehouseInventory (~line 2088) then modifies those shared ProductCombinationWarehouseInventory items in place (existingPwI.StockQuantity = ..., and Add/Remove on the shared list). When OutOfStockNotifications(product, combination, prevCombination) runs (~line 223), the multi-warehouse branch compares prevcombination.WarehouseInventory with combination.WarehouseInventory, which are the same objects, so "previously out of stock, now in stock" is never detected, both for the per-warehouse check and for the total-sum check.

The single-warehouse branch is not affected, since StockQuantity is a value type copied by the clone. The product-level path is not affected either: it snapshots prevMultiWarehouseStock into new ProductWarehouseInventory objects (~line 781).

Suggested fix

Deep-copy WarehouseInventory when snapshotting the previous state (e.g. in Clone() or in the service, create new ProductCombinationWarehouseInventory items with WarehouseId, StockQuantity, ReservedQuantity), or capture the previous per-warehouse quantities before PrepareCombinationWarehouseInventory mutates them. A unit test for the combination edit path with multiple warehouses would cover this.

Notes

Related: #880 (journaling manual stock changes), which touches the same manual stock edit flow.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions