Summary
For SNMP-enabled devices (switches, access points), OneUptime's Network Topology already auto-discovers neighbor relationships (via LLDP/CDP) and draws links automatically. For devices that only support ICMP monitoring (no SNMP — e.g. KPS units, registers, VoIP phones, non-manageable endpoints), there is no LLDP/CDP data available, so no automatic link discovery is possible. Today the only way to represent these devices in the topology is to manually create a link from the device to the switch port/switch it's physically connected to.
This does not scale. A single site ("WB Unit 0661" in the example) can have 30–40 ICMP-only end devices, each needing a manual link to the correct switch. Maintaining this manually across many sites is impractical.
Problem
- SNMP devices (switches/APs) → links auto-created via LLDP/CDP neighbor discovery. Works well.
- Router → switch links → not auto-created, but can be handled today with a link label rule ("connect all routers to switches"). Acceptable workaround.
- ICMP-only end devices (no SNMP, e.g. KPS, registers, VoIP endpoints) → no neighbor data exists, so the only option is a manual link per device.
- Manual links are also fragile: if an end device is later moved to a different switch port (e.g. after a failure or a physical re-cable), the manually created link becomes stale and shows an incorrect topology (device appears connected to a switch it's no longer on).
Describe the solution you'd like
For a given site, allow OneUptime to determine which switch an ICMP-monitored device is actually connected to, and automatically create/update that link in the Network Topology — scoped only to devices that have been added under that site (not global network scanning).
Describe alternatives you've considered
- For each site, look at the SNMP-managed switches already in that site's topology (their MAC address/ARP/CAM tables are typically queryable via SNMP).
- Cross-reference the MAC addresses of ICMP-only devices in the same site against each switch's CAM table to determine which switch port the device is currently plugged into.
- Automatically create (or move) the topology link between the device and the discovered switch, replacing the need for a manual link.
- Re-run this discovery periodically (similar to how LLDP/CDP topology already "updates automatically every minute") so that if a device is moved to a different switch/port, the topology link updates automatically instead of showing stale/incorrect information.
- Scope discovery strictly to devices within the same site — not a global scan across all sites.
Why this matters
- Manually linking 30–40 devices per site, across many sites, is not sustainable.
- A hardcoded manual link becomes false/misleading information the moment a device is physically moved to a different switch (e.g. during a failure or maintenance), which undermines trust in the topology view.
- This would bring ICMP-only end devices to parity with the automatic discovery already available for SNMP switches/APs.
Current workarounds in use
- Manual link creation per device (e.g. KPS 01 → Switch 01) — does not scale and goes stale.
- Link label rule to auto-connect routers to switches — works for router/switch relationships but doesn't help with ICMP end devices since there's no equivalent "neighbor" signal for them today.
Additional context
- OneUptime self-hosted
- Network Devices / Network Topology feature (Parent-Child topology view)
- Example site: WB Unit 0661 (Region 1700 / Market 1705) — 18 devices, mix of SNMP switches/APs and ICMP-only devices (KPS, registers, VoIP endpoints)

Summary
For SNMP-enabled devices (switches, access points), OneUptime's Network Topology already auto-discovers neighbor relationships (via LLDP/CDP) and draws links automatically. For devices that only support ICMP monitoring (no SNMP — e.g. KPS units, registers, VoIP phones, non-manageable endpoints), there is no LLDP/CDP data available, so no automatic link discovery is possible. Today the only way to represent these devices in the topology is to manually create a link from the device to the switch port/switch it's physically connected to.
This does not scale. A single site ("WB Unit 0661" in the example) can have 30–40 ICMP-only end devices, each needing a manual link to the correct switch. Maintaining this manually across many sites is impractical.
Problem
Describe the solution you'd like
For a given site, allow OneUptime to determine which switch an ICMP-monitored device is actually connected to, and automatically create/update that link in the Network Topology — scoped only to devices that have been added under that site (not global network scanning).
Describe alternatives you've considered
Why this matters
Current workarounds in use
Additional context