cw: WoT show criticism! (cause I know some people (including me, mostly) just wanna enjoy it and have fun!) I love the show and I'm sure I will continue to love it whether or not Rafe reads this and takes my advice 😜
Ok, but--
Now that I've watched E8...three times 🙈 the choice of making Mat a former Hero of the Horn feels weird to me (even though it's a valid suspicion based on the books!). It's because the central fixation of Mat's character is that he is no hero, despite always ending up being heroic.
Book!Mat does not 'identify' as a hero. Like all the other main characters, he finds himself constantly put in situations where duty and his own moral compass require heroic or brave acts, but he sees them as undertakings of duty or necessity. The last thing book!Mat would do when meeting the Heroes of the Horn is give an excited "I'm one of you!" As Brigitte makes clear multiple times, to be a hero of the Horn is to be tied to the Wheel in a similar manner to being ta'veren, and there's nothing book!Mat hates more than feeling trapped by Fate. The show has set up his arc as "I'm a bad person > actually I'm awesome!" whereas in the book it's more like "I don't want anything to do with this magic shit > I am, begrudgingly, embroiled in this magic shit but I don't like it!"
In fact, if I had to sum up The Wheel of Time in one sentence(!) it would be something like Being a hero sucks. RJ's central exploration is of small-town people being told the weight of the entire world rests on their shoulders. As Siuan says in the show, "The Wheel calls you to this, whether you can bear it or not." No one in the books wants to be a hero (except maybe Egwene? Discuss.)
I think that to really capture the feel of the books, the show is gonna have to lean into this more. They have tapped into it some, but the weight of duty, and especially in Rand's case, the enormity of being the Dragon Reborn, really hasn't been communicated in my opinion. Rand spends most of The Dragon Reborn in a walking fugue state, and so far, show!Rand's main concern has been rescuing Egwene from Ishamael.
I think they really need to dig into the complexity and horror of both the figure of the Dragon Reborn, the depression and angst that taking on that mantle brings to Rand, and the intensity of the madness. In the show Rand and Lan are having a loud discussion about him being DR in front of a Cairhien castle guard for goodness sake! Whereas in the book, Mat thinks Ingtar will kill Rand just for being able to channel, let alone being DR, and Perrin is just like, "yeah I bet he would."
I think the show can go along as it is being fun and a good fantasy show, but to truly capture the essence of Jordan's books, it needs to continue to cleave to the grim fate of being woven against your will into the Lace of Ages.